Can’t Afford Group Medical? You Can Still Offer Dental, Vision, Life and Disability
Information current as of November 14, 2026. Written by Brandon Hoobler, licensed Washington insurance broker.
Many small business owners assume benefits start and end with a medical plan. When the medical quote comes back too high, they offer nothing. That leaves a lot on the table. You do not need a group medical plan to offer dental, vision, life insurance or disability coverage. Those plans cost far less than medical, and voluntary benefits paid by employees through payroll can round out a package your people will actually use.
The quick answer
- Dental, vision, group life and disability can all be offered without a group medical plan.
- They cost a fraction of medical. The average employer medical premium in 2025 was $9,325 a year for single coverage and $26,993 for family coverage (KFF).
- Voluntary benefits, such as accident, critical illness and hospital coverage, are paid by employees through payroll at no premium cost to the company.
- Most of these can be paid pre-tax through a Section 125 plan. Disability is the exception to think through.
You do not need medical to offer benefits
Dental, vision, group life and disability are separate insurance plans. Carriers write them on their own, without a medical plan, under their own participation and eligibility rules. Voluntary plans work the same way.
These are also the benefits most employees use every year: cleanings, eye exams and glasses. Life and disability coverage protect a household when something goes wrong. A package without medical is still a real benefits package, and employees notice it. See our pages on group dental, group vision and group life and disability.
How the cost compares with medical
Employer medical is expensive, and it keeps climbing. Washington approved an average increase of 16.7% for 2027 small group medical plans (Washington OIC). Dental, vision, life and disability premiums are a small fraction of medical per employee. Exact rates depend on the carrier, plan design, ages and how many people enroll, so the way to know is a quote on your census. What surprises most owners is how much they can offer for less than one employee’s medical premium.
What a package without medical can include
| Benefit | What it does | Who usually pays |
|---|---|---|
| Group dental | Cleanings, fillings and larger work, with in-network pricing | Employer, employee or shared |
| Group vision | Eye exams, glasses and contacts | Often employee-paid or shared |
| Group term life | A death benefit for the employee’s family | Often employer-paid for a base amount |
| Short-term disability | Replaces part of a paycheck for weeks or months after an off-the-job injury, illness or childbirth | Employer or employee |
| Long-term disability | Replaces part of income during a longer disability | Employer or employee |
| Voluntary benefits | Accident, critical illness, hospital indemnity, cancer and individual life coverage that pay cash benefits | Employee, through payroll |
| Telehealth | Virtual doctor visits for the employee and family, often with a copay only when used | Varies by plan |
Washington’s Paid Family and Medical Leave program already replaces part of wages for some leaves, so ask how a short-term disability plan works alongside it. Our voluntary benefits page explains how payroll-paid coverage works.
Which deductions should be pre-tax
A Section 125 cafeteria plan lets employees pay their share of certain premiums before tax. Dental and vision premiums are commonly paid this way. Aflac sets up a premium-only Section 125 plan at no cost when a group offers its voluntary products. Many voluntary plans can also be paid pre-tax, depending on the plan, so we confirm the setup with the carrier.
Disability is the one to think through. If the employer pays disability premiums, or employees pay them pre-tax through a cafeteria plan, the benefits are generally taxable when paid. If employees pay with after-tax dollars, the benefits are generally tax-free (IRS Publication 525). Many employers run disability deductions after tax for that reason.
Group term life has its own rule. Employer-paid group term life coverage above $50,000 creates taxable imputed income for the employee (IRS Publication 15-B).
A real example: an electrical contractor without medical
One Washington electrical contractor we work with priced group medical and could not make the numbers work. Instead of offering nothing, the company put together a package employees can see and use: group dental and vision, group life and disability, plus Aflac voluntary coverage paid through payroll.
Employees can also buy a 20-year term life policy through payroll, guaranteed issue up to $50,000, and families get a telehealth plan with no plan cost and a copay only when they use it. Everyone enrolls online through Employee Navigator, and we walk employees through the options. If medical becomes affordable later, the company can add it without changing anything it offers today.
Rules to know before you offer them
- Participation minimums. Carriers set minimum enrollment for dental, vision, life and disability, and the minimums differ. One carrier we use requires 20% participation for group dental and vision. Employer-paid coverage makes any minimum easy to meet.
- Eligibility. Set the hours threshold and waiting period in writing and apply them the same way to everyone. Our hourly and seasonal teams page covers common designs.
- Voluntary benefits. These can start with as few as three enrolled employees.
- 50 or more full-time equivalents. These benefits do not satisfy the ACA requirement for applicable large employers to offer medical coverage, and an applicable large employer with no medical plan can face a penalty. See ACA compliance.
Explain it, or employees will not use it
Benefits only build loyalty when people understand them. In our experience, when voluntary benefits are explained well, 70% or more of a group often enrolls, even though most employees have little in savings. We hold group and one-on-one meetings, in person or by video, at no added cost, and run enrollment on Employee Navigator.
If medical becomes affordable later, these plans stay in place. You can add a group medical plan, a level-funded plan or an ICHRA on top.
Frequently asked questions
Can a company offer dental and vision without offering medical?
Yes. Carriers write group dental and vision as stand-alone plans, subject to their own participation and eligibility rules.
Can employees pay for dental and vision pre-tax?
Yes, when their contributions run through a Section 125 cafeteria plan. The employer needs a written plan document, and some voluntary carriers, including Aflac, set one up at no cost when the group offers their products.
Should disability premiums be taken pre-tax?
Usually not, if the goal is tax-free benefits. Disability benefits are generally tax-free when employees paid the premiums with after-tax dollars, and taxable when premiums were paid pre-tax or by the employer.
Do these benefits satisfy the ACA if we have 50 or more full-time employees?
No. Applicable large employers need to offer medical coverage that meets ACA standards to avoid penalties. Dental, vision, life and disability do not count toward that requirement.
How many employees do we need for voluntary benefits?
Voluntary benefits can start with as few as three enrolled employees. Employees pay for them through payroll, so there is no premium cost to the company.
Ready to build a package without medical?
Send us your employee list through our secure upload, and we will price dental, vision, life, disability and voluntary options side by side. Call (206) 653-9636 or contact us to schedule a no-obligation benefits review.
General information, not legal or tax advice. Plan availability, participation rules, rates and tax treatment depend on the carrier, the plan and your payroll setup. Confirm pre-tax and after-tax choices with your tax adviser.